Skip to main content

Unity Multiplayer Networking pitfalls

So recently I need to find a way to get two Unity projects on different machines talking and sharing data. The data shared is nothing like multiplayer games, far from it, it was just a notification of an event flag that became true on one machine. So if a special event happens on one machine then the other machine will also know. This is just sending a string or an int as a flag, simple!

My first attempt was to use Unity's Unet Multiplayer Networking system. It looks easy enough to use right ? So I followed the Networking tutorial here. Turns out it was not as smooth as I'd hoped...

  • The server only works as standalone. So we need to build the application and run as standalone. Not a big problem, but for those who don't read the manuals (like me, hehe) this is the first obstacle. Just running on the Editor will not work.
  • However, it does not work between computers. I was running a mac and a windows machine and although they could see each other just fine (ping worked) the Unity projects could not talk to each other.
  • After many hours googling, I tried everything I found, disabling firewall, antivirus, tutorials, sample codes etc. It just didn't work.
During my search I saw many people posting the same thing, basically it doesn't work between different devices on a local network. I guess there must be something I did wrong somewhere but the documentations and tutorials do not cover multiple devices on LAN.

So the next thing I tried was to use the transport layer (LLAPI) as discussed in this post. I got it to work on the same PC, but not over the network. It turns out that in order to get it to work you need to connect the two devices to each other. In other words,  if you have devices on 192.168.2.10 and 192.168.2.12 you need to have 
connectionId = NetworkTransport.Connect(socketId, "192.168.2.10", remoteDevicePort, 0, out error);

on the machine with the IP 192.168.2.12 and conversely,
connectionId = NetworkTransport.Connect(socketId, "192.168.2.12", 4999, 0, out error);

on the machine with the IP 192.168.2.10.
Oh, and last but not least, the two devices need to run the same version of Unity. If the versions don't match, the connection may fail silently.

With the above setup, I managed to get two PCs on LAN to send messages back and forth as P2P.

Hope this post helps.

PS : The repository of this test project.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Installing a custom ROM on Android (on the GT-N8013)

It's been a while since my last entry and since it is a new start in 2019, I thought I'd write something about "gone with the old and in with the new". I've had my Samsung Galaxy Note 10.1 (pnotewifi) since 2014, and it's one of the early Galaxy Note tablet series. It has served me well all this years but now it just sits there collecting dust. My old Samsung GT-N8013 I've known a long time about custom Android ROMs like CyanogenMod but has never had the motivation to try them out, until now ! Overview of the process For beginners like me, I didn't have an understanding of the installation process and so it looked complicated and it was one of the reasons I was put off in trying the custom ROM. I just want to say, it's not complicated at all!   Basically you will need to Prepare an SD card and install Android SDK (you need adb ). Install a custom boot loader ( TWRP is the de facto tool at the moment). Use adb to copy custom...
15 comments
Read more

Building a native plugin for Intel Realsense D415 for Unity

Based on a previous post , I decided to write a plugin for the Intel Realsense SDK methods so we can use these methods from within Unity. FYI Intel also has their own Unity wrapper in their Github repository , but for our projects, I needed to perform image processing with OpenCV and passing the results to Unity instead of just the raw image/depth data. There is a plugin called OpenCVForUnity to use OpenCV functions from Unity but previous experiments indicate the image processing inside Unity can take a long time. I hope this post can help someone else who wants to use Intel's cameras or any other devices natively in Unity. Test Environment Windows 10 64bit Unity 2017.2.0f3 x64 bit Realsense SDK from Intel CMake 3.0 or higher Steps Checkout the native plugin code here . Don't worry about the other projects in the same repository. The relevant code is in the link above. Checkout the Unity sample project here . However, instead of master you need to go to the br...
5 comments
Read more

OpenCV native plugin for Unity in IOS

In one of my recent projects, I needed to use OpenCV from within Unity, in IOS. The asset called OpenCVForUnity is overkill because I didn't need the whole OpenCV library, just a few functions. In addition, this asset does not implement the whole OpenCV library so unless you know that what you need is included you may find it lacking when you discover it does not support some functions you need. As my project involves some trial and error and mixing algorithms together I decided to go with a native plugin. Overview In IOS, a native library is built as a bundle . We need to put this bundle inside Unity's Plugins/OSX folder to use it. Therefore, we need to create two projects. An XCode project to build the native plugin. A Unity project to use the plugin. Dependencies Of course, since we need to use OpenCV we will have to install it first. Tutorials on installing OpenCV on IOS are abundant and I will not include them here. Assuming you have installed OpenCV go to t...
2 comments
Read more